And the winner is...
Katniss!
Welcome to The YA Sisterhood and round 3 of The Tournament of Heroines, The Extraordinary Eight! Can you guys believe we're already down to eight heroines? Crazy! Thank you in advance for your participation in our Tournament of Heroines! We hope you make some friends (and not too many enemies), discover some fantastic books, and have a lot of fun!
Katniss!
Welcome to The YA Sisterhood and round 3 of The Tournament of Heroines, The Extraordinary Eight! Can you guys believe we're already down to eight heroines? Crazy! Thank you in advance for your participation in our Tournament of Heroines! We hope you make some friends (and not too many enemies), discover some fantastic books, and have a lot of fun!
Some general rules before we begin:
There may be some spoilers in the following post. We've tried to keep it fairly general, but overall, this Tourney will not be spoiler-free. So beware.
Secondly, You are welcome to write your own comments about either character in the comments section, but we will not tolerate rudeness. The minute it crosses over from logical argument into character bashing, your comments will be deleted and your vote canceled. POLLS WILL BE OPEN FOR 24 HOURS AND WILL CLOSE AT 12:01AM EST ON DECEMBER 31st.
And now for the match....
My name is Penelope, and I run the book review blog: The Reading Fever. I am honored to be Katniss’ advocate, and will be blogging and tweeting about Katniss’ progress throughout the tournament. You can follow me using the links below for #TeamKatniss updates.
1. About Katniss
The bird, the pin, the song, the berries, the watch, the cracker, the dress that burst into flames. I am the Mockingjay. The one that survived despite the Capitol's plans. The symbol of the rebellion.
-Katniss, Catching Fire by Suzanne Collins (pg. 386-387)
![]() |
| Credit: Entertainment Weekly |
She is fiercely protective of those she loves, and has proven she will go to any lengths to ensure their safety. Not one to be easily swayed or broken, she proves to the Capitol that no matter their methods, they can't control everyone.
Also known as: Catnip, the Mockingjay, and The Girl On Fire.
2. Best Attributes
A mockingjay is a creature the capitol never intended to exist. They hadn’t counted on the highly controlled jabberjay having the brains to adapt to the wild...They hadn’t anticipated its will to live.As tempting as it is to name Katniss' hunting skills and her innate sense of survival as her best attributes, that just wouldn't be completely true. Everything Katniss does in the series can be attributed to one of these: love, compassion, fear.
-Katniss, Catching Fire by Suzanne Collins (pg. 92)
Her first act--entering the Hunger Games in place of her younger sister, Prim--was done out of her incredible love for Prim, and fear for Prim's safety. She is pushed to survive by fear of dying and leaving her family without a provider; called into action by compassion for Rue and Peeta (competitors in the hunger games); compelled to accept the title of The Mockingjay (symbol of the rebellion) by compassion for those enduring the destruction the Capitol brings. She takes what the world gives her and reacts to it in a way that benefits those around her; letting love, compassion, and fear guide her. These are her best attributes.
3. What makes Katniss a true heroine?
I’m moving in toward the camera now, carried forward by my rage. “President Snow says he’s sending us a message? Well, I have one for him. You can torture us and bomb us and burn our districts to the ground, but do you see that?” One of the cameras follows as I point to the planes burning on the roof of the warehouse across from us. The Capitol seal on a wing glows clearly through the flames. “Fire is catching!” I am shouting now, determined that he will not miss a word. “And if we burn, you burn with us!”The quote above is from Katniss. At this point in the story, Katniss has already been through the hunger games, has witnessed the pain, torture, and death, of loved ones, has been forced to kill, seen her home destroyed, and has witnessed the extreme lengths the Capitol will go to in order to have total control--and yet these things only empower her to act.
-Katniss, Mockingjay by Suzanne Collins (pg. 99-100)
To me a true heroine is someone who rises above her circumstances, who keeps going despite being knocked down, and most importantly: a heroine inspires others to keep going as well. Katniss is a true heroine.
4. Why should you vote for Katniss instead of Alex?
![]() |
| Credit: kara-lija on DeviantArt |
Why wouldn’t you vote for the Mockingjay? She is the driving force behind the entire rebellion; the very hope of the oppressed; the one who brought an end to the devastating war.
So she doesn't exactly have a winning attitude. We can't all be perky and upbeat. She's only human, and would like nothing more than to be left in peace with her family for the rest of her life. But life rarely goes in the direction we hope, and when Katniss is forced down the path that leads to her becoming the Mockingjay, she accepts the title with respect, and recognizes the honor in being the Mockingjay.
It takes stamina and determination to be a symbol to the oppressed. It takes knowledge, cunning, and good instincts, to make good on the hope such a position gives to others. After a while, Katniss sees that she can no longer be a mere symbol; when an opportunity comes, she bravely takes matters into her own hands, risking her life--and sadly, losing some friends--to carry out the plans to bring an end to the war. And she succeeds.
*END PLOT SPOILERS*
Because when it comes down to it, Katniss comes through. Whether her plan is legit, risky, or completely crazy, you can bet she knows what she's doing, and that she will come through for you.
So I ask again: Why wouldn't you vote for the Mockingjay?
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
About Alex Andros:
First off, according to Aiden, this is what he thought of Alex when he first saw her...after those three years:
Long, thick chestnut colored hair fell past a chest that had grown in the last three years. Her face was oval shape; lips full like a pure-blood’s. Cheekbones high and eyebrows delicately arched over two wide, brown eyes. Even with the faint purplish bruises marring an otherwise flawless complexion, she was… unbelievable.And in Alex's own words:
Beautiful.
With all the dirt and overall grossness gone, I looked just like my mom. Long dark hair fell down my back; I had those high cheekbones and full lips most pures did. I was a bit curvier than Mom's willowy frame and I didn't have her amazing eyes. Mine were brown, homely old brown.Alex is irrational, unstable, out of control, wild, crazy, rash, and stubborn but that makes her everything that she is, which is a fighter. She is unpredictable and very quick to act but she believes strongly in what is right versus what is wrong. She hardly ever lets anything faze her and that makes her high lariously funny. She says the darnest things at the most inappropriate times, lol, but what's life without some humor? She's uber sarcastic and tough and edgy and all-out fierce. She lives in this world where all that matters are the pures and their safety. She doesn't want to be forced into servitude so she is in the process of training to be a Sentinel - one who fights and kills daimons → the scary, looking things that will suck the life out of you. Alex isn't a fighter just physically, but she's also a fighter internally...if you get what I mean. She won't take anyone's B. S and she won't ever give up, you can count on that. Plus, Aiden said this ↓ ↓ ↓ about Alex's...qualities that I had listed above:
...I always thought your irrational nature was a flaw. It's not. It's what makes you so strong.*nods* Uh-huh, what he said.
Alex's Best Attributes:
Alex stands out to me among all the other female characters because she's funny. I know, anyone can be funny. Okay, not anyone but it doesn't take a mad scientist to crack a joke here and there. Alex is such a smart mouth; she speaks without thinking and that totally comes with its consequences, haha, but you can't help but think, "Omg, I was so thinking that!" She says stuff that you wouldn't say out loud or stuff that you would bite back. She's definitely hard to forget because she has such a character; that's why when the nominations for this tourney began, Alex immediately came to mind. You won't be able to forget her if you tried. Also, she stands out to me because she can definitely hold her own. She'll take things into her own hands when needed; she won't back down and she indubitably won't take no for an answer. Alex is rebellious and at times, that might sound like a bad thing but like I've mentioned, she believes in what's right and if a little rebellious-ness is needed, where's the harm in that?!
What makes Alex a true heroine?
As defined by...dictionary dot com, a heroine is:
In my opinion, a true heroine is someone who isn't afraid to be heard, someone who speaks up and fights back when they see something that is unjust; someone who isn't afraid to dive head first into a difficult situation. Also, a true heroine is courageous and brave and strong; someone who will step up when needed. And according to that, Alex is all of the above. Alex is a fighter, she's resilient and always bounces back after a horrible tragedy occurs. Like they say, what doesn't kill you only makes you stronger. Because of what she's been through, it has shaped her into the kind of character that she is. You can count on her to save your butt whenever you're in a dire situation, that's for sure. Alex is a true heroine to me because she doesn't need a man to get her out of a ditch when she falls into one. She'll tire out all possible chances of saving herself before she'll resort to a man. Did I forget to mention that Alex can stab stuff? Oh yes, absolutely! She's a feisty little thing! Heck, she don't need no dagger or blade, she'll take you down with a garden spade! (OH WHAT?! That rhymed right there! I'm a genius! ;))
- a woman of distinguished courage or ability, admired for her brave deeds and noble qualities.
- the principal female character in a story, play, film, etc.
Why should we vote for Alex instead of Katniss?
Alex and Katniss are both survivors. They do what it takes to survive and get the eff outta...whatever horrible situation they are in. I mean, Katniss is the queen when it comes to a bow and arrow and Alex is a straight up boss when it comes to daggers so I wouldn't want to mess with either one of them because I don't even have to be in close proximity for them to harm me.
You should vote for Alex instead of Katniss because Alex was born a fighter. She was born into a world where having a tough skin was necessary. Alex is fierce, stable, strong-willed and her determination will never waver. Strip Alex of everything she has, and she will still fight to the death if it means that she will survive. I mean, that's basically Survival Skills 101. ;)
Alex has so much potential to be the top heroine of the whole tournament. Half-Blood has only been out in the world for two months and twelve days and already, any bookworm who has picked up a copy has immediately fallen in love with Alex's character and that's not for nothing. As we follow her throughout the series, I believe she will rise and be one of the most top-notch, butt kickin' heroine ever because she has what it takes to go over and beyond it all to survive.
Vote for Alex because....well, basically because I'm telling you too. What else?! Oh and because Alex is like...the underdog of all underdogs!
Anything else you'd like to add?
Now you know the #HalfBloodLegion went wild with their incentives last time and well...we're bringing it ten times more for this round because our passion for our gal, Alex, is just a fierce, burning fire (ha, that made me laugh a bit) that we can't seem to put out. Some might think this has come down to a bribery sort of thing instead for the character herself, but once someone is ignited with passion, you can't stop 'em. ;) If you haven't read Half-Blood...well then, you've kind of, sort of been deprived. I'm just sayin'. For this round, the brilliant JLA has offered up:500 votes: a teaser from Onyx
750 votes: a teaser from Pure and Onyx
1,000 votes: a POV from Daemon (Obsidian)
And that's not all.
1250 votes: a teaser from Seth's POV in Pure
1500 votes: a teaser from Shadows
Winning votes: a teaser from Pure, Shadows, Onyx, and Cursed
Aaaaaaaaaannnnd
For every 1000 votes, JLA will give away an ARC of Pure, up to 6000 votes
-ARCs will be given away on Twitter
Also, don't forget that my giveaway for a copy of Daimon, Half-Blood and Pure is still going on. Head on over to this post to enter for a chance at devouring this amazing series quicker than you can say:
UNDERDOGS FTW!
VOTE ALEX. VOTE ALEX. VOTE ALEX.
*VOTING IS NOW CLOSED*






WOOT WOOT! FIRST VOTE! ALEX FOR THE WIN!
ReplyDeleteUnderdogs unite! Team Alex all the way!
ReplyDeleteJust voted AlexFTW
ReplyDeleteGO GOGOGO GOGOGOGGOO TEAM ALEX <3
ReplyDeleteEven though Alex knocked out Rose, I hear she's pretty awesome so I voted for Alex!
ReplyDelete#TeamAlex! :D
ReplyDeleteKatniss all the way.
ReplyDeleteAlex all the way! Underdogs for the win!
ReplyDeleteLet's do this Half-Blood Legion!
Great post Momo! You're a rhyming genius!
Katniss FTW! :D
ReplyDeleteLet's go, Alex! :) Go Half-Blood Legion!
ReplyDeleteGo Alex!
ReplyDeleteKatniss was also born a fighter. Living in a world containing The Hunger Games doesn't allow you to be a softie. With her father dying when she was so young and her mother practially comatose because of it, Katniss had to become the family's provider. Breaking the law and hunting to survive, caring for her sister when her mother couldn't, and wouldn't. And even sacrificing herself when Prim was chosen as tribute. And then forcing herself to kill others while trying not to be killed herself. Having to go underground and become the savior of the entire nation. I haven't read Alex's books but I know that Katniss is also pretty darn tough and I believe she can win this. Team Katniss FTW!!
ReplyDeleteLove both of them, but definitely for Alex!
ReplyDeleteI adore both girls but my vote goes to the kickass underdog ALEX. VOTE FOR ALEX!!!
ReplyDelete#TeamKatniss FTW! Katniss is an amazing example of a heroine. She not only fought for her life, but she also risked it for those she loved most. Even with the ultimate power threatening to kill her, her courage never faltered. So then, again, I say: TEAM KATNISS <3
ReplyDeleteWill Katniss blow another competitor out of the water? pssh, duh! TEAM KATNISS!!!(:
ReplyDeleteTeam Alex!! FTW
ReplyDeleteFantastic argument as always, Momo! :)
ReplyDeleteLoving the comments! @BookNerd & @MarissaErin, I totally agree with your thoughts.
go alex
ReplyDeleteGOOO TEAM ALEX!!! #HALFBLOODLEGION
ReplyDeleteHaven't read the books but went for the underdog Team Alex..ya all are blowing up twitter...feels like twilight all over again. new follower by the way. Stop by and ck out my blog, I review everything from YA to horror..
ReplyDeletehttp://www.kimbathecaffeinatedbookreviewer.blogspot.com/
#HalfBloodLegion FTW
ReplyDelete@kimba88 I don't know about Alex's books but The Hunger Games are NOTHING like Twlight. They're better :)
ReplyDeleteThanks Penelope! Same to you!
ReplyDeleteTeam Alex! Vote for Alex!
ReplyDeleteBoth girls are fighters but Alex keeps her humor during the fight! Love that!
ReplyDelete"I was gonna be super pissed in the afterlife if I died a virgin in this crap hole." (HALF-BLOOD)
Support Alex!
Valerie
StuckInBooks.com
This is TOUGH! I'm sorry Katniss but I gotta go with Alex!
ReplyDeleteTEAM ALEX FTW!!
Karen @ I Read To Escape
Alex! I hope she wins! <3
ReplyDeleteKATNISS!
ReplyDeleteALEXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX all the way!!!
ReplyDeleteThanks for everyone's comments! :) I really hope Alex pulls through in this match!
ReplyDeleteAlex for the win!
Alex FTW !!!
ReplyDeleteThese are two different people and its gonna be hard for me to chose between them, although Katniss lives in a world where danger is everywhere. She learnt to figth for her life with a bow and arrow and already has lost people that are really close to her heart (Her dad and Prim.. Sorry this is kind of spoilery) and not to mention District 12, so through my eyes. Sorry Alex... The Mockingjay gets my vote. Team Katniss till the day I die. But I still love you Alex.
ReplyDeleteIn The Hunger Games, it's not that easy to tell right from wrong or good from evil. The Hunger Games, which pit children and teenagers against each other in a fight to the death, are evil. The Capitol runs the Games, therefore it is evil. But those who have finished the final book, Mockingjay, will know that good people can do bad things, and it is not so easy to label one side as evil because everyone commits atrocities to a certain degree. Heroines who face off against demons and vampires and dark fairies are brave and strong and admirable. But in the real world, it is not so easy to recognize a demon. In The Hunger Games, it's hard to tell what's real from what's not. We know it's not easy to recognize the right solution amongst many shades of grey. It's not easy to identify your enemy when they all live and breathe as you, and have their own dreams and faults. The Hunger Games gives us an arena of grey, and Katniss mirrors our struggles in figuring out what's right from what's wrong.
ReplyDeleteWe envy heroines who "kick butt", speak their mind and win their own fights. We want to be like them because it is difficult to be cool in the face of adversity. But we are unlikely to face real demons or evil creatures in our lifetime. What we face instead are ambiguous situations, people trying to do what they think is right, and everyday arguments that wear away at our spirits until we don't know how we can go on. I admire Katniss because she shows that it's absolutely not easy to carry on. Only half the struggle is in the physical fight; the other half lies in surviving the aftermath of your conscience. You can't kill someone without seeing their faces in your nightmares. You can't win a war without losing a part of yourself. Sometimes it's harder to live than die, and we know this from our own lives and experiences. What Katniss shows us is that by living day by day, by taking each nightmare as it comes, we can live on. War is pain and suffering and loss, not fun and adventure. People you count on and trust can change and become twisted. You will be hurt and betrayed and used by people, but if you take the chance to live on, you may, like Katniss, find that hope returns. Like the dandelion in the spring.
"Only half the struggle is in the physical fight; the other half lies in surviving the aftermath of your conscience." <---Very true! Loved reading this, @ruroken90.
ReplyDeleteKATNISSSSSS! <3
ReplyDeleteI love both but I vote for Alex. I'm crossing my fingers now.
ReplyDeleteALEX FTW!
ReplyDeleteCome on Half-Blood Legion. We can so do this!
#TeamKatniss!!! Crossing my fingers to hope that tAlex doesn't beat her :D
ReplyDeleteTeam Alex - we want those extras !!!!
ReplyDeleteKATNISS EVERDEEN!!!
ReplyDeleteKatniss FTW!
ReplyDeleteI've not read the Covenant series, but I didn't like the Hunger Games, so I'm voting for Alex :)
ReplyDelete#Team Katniss! She's my heroine **
ReplyDeleteTeam Alex!
ReplyDeleteGo Alex!!!!! As much as I love Kat, Alex is my girl.
ReplyDeletekatniss!!! <3
ReplyDeleteKatniss!
ReplyDeleteGo Alex!!! :)
ReplyDeleteKatniss Everdeen!!!
ReplyDeleteKatniss all the way!
ReplyDeleteKATNISS!!!!!!!!! Just think of what she's been through!
ReplyDeleteThanks everyone so much for stopping by and voting! These matches are so much fun! I just wanted to give a quick reminder though that if you put major spoilers or bash anyone in anyway in the comments we will have to erase them! Everyone keep up the awesomeness!
ReplyDeleteKatniss is the BEST!
ReplyDeleteVoted for Alex! Go underdog! I think she deserves a chance!
ReplyDeleteKatniss Everdeen ALL the way!!!!! She's strong, independant, and loyal. She's the best YA role model that I have ever read about before. VOt for Katniss Everdeen!!!!
ReplyDeleteI totally respect Katniss and LOVED Hunger Games, but c'mon--seriously, Alex would kick her butt! See some of what Alex has been through by grabbing DAIMON, the free prequel novella to HALF-BLOOD, from the publisher's website: http://www.site.spencerhillpress.com/Daimon.php
ReplyDeleteTeam ALEX!
Katniss all the way. I wasn't a fan of her in Mockingjay, but in The Hunger Games and Catching Fire she was one of my fav YA protagonists.
ReplyDeleteI am a huge Hunger Games fan and love Katniss but I am totally TEAM ALEX!
ReplyDeleteIf you have not read Daimon, Half Blood & (Pure is not out yet, BUT I have read it...), you really should! THEY ARE INCREDIBLE! Alex is one tough cookie and takes no stuff from anyone!
Half Blood POWER!!!!
I absolutely adore Katniss, but I'm reading Half-Blood right now and loving Alex, so I've gotta go with Team Alex!!
ReplyDelete#TEAMKATNISSFTW DO NOT!! COMPARE THE HUNGER GAMES TO TWILIGHT PPL IT IS NOT COOL!
ReplyDeleteI LOVE LOVE YOUR COMMENT @ruroken90 yeah go katniss
ReplyDeleteGO KATNISS !!!!!!!!! <3 <3
ReplyDeleteTEAM ALEX!!! :)
ReplyDeleteTeam Katniss all the way!!
ReplyDeleteUmm duh KATNISS FTW. Even tho I voted for Alex when the competition was between her and Rose because I believed she was the true heroine on that case she doesn't stand a chance against Katniss or any of Cassandra Clares heroines. Go Katniss!!!
ReplyDeleteKatniss ftw! :) ♥
ReplyDeleteKatniss, she is the bravest out of both of them! Vote for the Mockingjay!
ReplyDeleteKATNISS FTW!!
ReplyDeleteKATNISSSSSSSSS!!
ReplyDeleteThats right all you peeps!!! Vote for the Mockingjay!!! Team Katniss until the day I die. Let's go Katniss!!! Woohoo!!!
ReplyDeleteI think both of them are amazing, but I honestly have to with Katniss. She volunteered for her sister, Prim, so her sister wouldn't have to suffer the terrifying place which is the Hunger Games. Now she's a true heroine.
ReplyDeleteALEX! All the way!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteThis is a truly hard decision. Both girls are truly deserving heroines. That being said, Alex is who I have had to go with on this one.
ReplyDeleteALEX!!
ReplyDeleteAlex all the way!!
ReplyDeleteAlex ALL THE WAY!! I love Katniss, but UNDERDOGS FTW!!! WE ARE SPARTA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteKATNISS!!!!!
ReplyDeleteKATNISS FOREVER! I haven't even read the Covenant series but I could never pick anyone besides Katniss because The Hunger Games is my life! The Covenant series does sound interesting though, so can anyone tell me what it's about? Also, what's the first book called and who is the author? THANKS!
ReplyDelete@ far post girl the first book is called Half-Blood and the author is Jennifer L Armentrout. It is amazing you should check it out. Go Alex!
ReplyDeleteCongrats to Katniss and her tributes! You guys put up one helluva fight! Great win! Good luck in the next match!
ReplyDeleteAnd my #HalfBloodLegion - you guys...I have no words to describe how much I love you guys! You guys rock to no end! ;) We did Alex proud!
TONIGHT WE DINE IN HELL!
THIIIIIIIIIIIIIIS. IIIIISSSSSSSSSSS. #SPAAAAAAARRRRRRRRTAAAA!
You rock, Momo! What a wonderful job you did as Alex's advocate! Team MOMO! :)
ReplyDeleteI was listening to Deep Shadows by T.T.L. while i read Katniss' part, and it was awesome. Are you Penelope allowed to post the trailer for The Hunger Games on here because that would totally win over alot of votes when we go up against Tessa and Clary.
ReplyDelete